As a lifelong Tolkien fan since secondary school, I have long wanted to do some “proper research” on Lord of The Rings and the wider legendarium. But somehow it was not until summer 2026 as I turned 81 that there was any time to spare.
But in that summer I put together a plan to do an LLM-imbued Masters of Research dissertation on a novel topic within Tolkien studies. The aim was to get to around 25,000 words, comfortably above the usual MSc dissertation limit but still far short of the volume for an Arts DPhil.
The overall brief is to look at several liminal aspects of Middle Earth within a framework of logical deduction from the works and commentaries – hence the obvious title (obvious to a mathematical logician) Axioms of Middle Earth.
Sadly for various personal and family reasons free days in the summer were far fewer than planned so the project is as yet incomplete – but some useful intermediate outputs are around. It was particularly liberating to relax my rigid strictures on Defensive Markdown and systematic citations and let the LLM horses gallop where they wished. Of course after “storming” comes “norming” and then the boring “reforming” but not quite yet.
Topics so far identified and worked on have been:
- What can we deduce of what is beyond the published map of Middle Earth?
- In what way could Middle Earth geography have mutated after the Fourth Age into the geography of Modern Earth?
- Why is there no trace of Gondor now? (Bizarrely, less than there is for Numenor.) What went wrong? Was it an existing flaw or a new one? Can we blame the Ice Age?
- How can we classify (directly or by logical deduction) the various oddities (Bombadil, etc) into the Valar/Maiar/speaking peoples taxonomy?
The project is based on a comprehensive and still-developing bibliography, which gives a basis to various Probes, which may or may not turn into Chapters. Probes tend to have sub-probes (or Appendices).
For reasons connected to my official studies I wanted to challenge some allegations that LLMs were not good at developing PowerPoint slides. Now Probe 4 Appendix A on the Future of the Valar had a great structure, but it was very under-illustrated. (As scholarly material often is.) So I gave Manus its head and ask for a well-illustrated presentation. And I got one. See the versions of it below.
Material:
- Report in Markdown (Note: for WordPress reasons this is a TXT file of Markdown content)
- Report in Word
- Report in PDF
- Presentation in PPTX
- Presentation in PDF
- Presentation in GIF
- Presentation in MP4
In future these methdological postings will contain the full range of material.
Out of interest, the prompt to create the PowerPoint was really simple:
Make a presentation in PowerPoint out of this report in a graphic style reminiscent of LOTR films or even the Amazon series if you get stuck! Ideally add a couple of open source Valarian images
But as usual, Manus over-delivered!
